Shadow Work When Someone Attacks You: A Plain Guide to Jung's Projection
/What Jung's shadow and projection mean when someone is yelling at you, what to say, and when the attacker is simply right. Plus a pot of basil.
TL;DR: Sometimes the person yelling at you is fighting something in their own head and you happened to be standing there. Sometimes they’re right about you. Shadow work is figuring out which one, and you can’t do that while you’re still yelling back.
Somebody’s coming at you. Your boss, your partner, some stranger in the comments who hates the way you worded one sentence. Your gut wants to build the case, stack up the evidence and win.
Hold off on that. I’ve written before that it’s never about you. Most of the time that holds. Sometimes it’s very much about you, and you need a way to tell the difference.
What is the shadow in Jung’s psychology?
The shadow is the stuff about yourself you decided was unacceptable and shoved out of sight. Carl Jung used the word for the traits a person disowns because they don’t fit the self they show people, or the self their family, church or culture signed off on.
People assume that means the dark stuff. Plenty of it is ordinary:
- Anger. “I’m not an angry person.”
- Ambition. Wanting credit feels gross, so you pretend you don’t.
- Laziness. Somebody taught you rest is a character flaw.
- Pride. Humility turned into your whole personality.
Burying a trait doesn’t kill it. It leaks. Passive aggression, a blowup over a dish in the sink, a weird hot hatred for the guy who openly does the exact thing you banned in yourself.
What is projection, and why does it matter when someone attacks you?
Projection is when someone sees in you a trait they won’t admit is in them. Say a guy calls you arrogant. Maybe he grew up believing that putting yourself forward is shameful, so he killed that off in himself. Then you walk in with some confidence and he can’t stand to look at it.
A few that come up over and over:
- “You’re so judgmental,” from someone whose inner voice is a prosecutor.
- “You think you’re better than everyone,” from someone who loses every comparison they run in their head.
- “You’re selfish,” from someone who can’t say no and resents anybody who can.
- “You’re cold,” from someone who’s scared to death of being seen.
These are guesses. You can’t read a stranger’s childhood off one insult, and you’ll look like an ass if you try. What you can notice is when the heat is way bigger than whatever actually happened.
Is the person attacking me always projecting?
No. Sometimes they’re right. Sometimes they’re wrong for boring reasons: bad information, no sleep, or they’re reacting to a real thing you really did.
This is where pop shadow work goes off the rails. If every criticism is somebody else’s projection, you’ve built armor nothing can get through. That armor is a shadow too. It’s the part of you that can’t stand being wrong.
Once you’ve cooled off, run three questions:
- Is there a fact in what they said that I can check?
- Would somebody neutral watching this agree with them on anything?
- Is the size of the reaction way out of line with what happened?
Yes on the first two? Take the hit and fix it. If it’s mostly the third, projection is probably part of the story. Usually it’s some of each.
Also worth knowing: the shadow is a Jungian idea, not a tested treatment. Jungian therapy as a whole has some outcome studies, mostly patient and therapist ratings, and no randomized trials. Shadow work as a do-it-yourself practice has close to nothing. Use it to ask yourself better questions. Don’t use it as proof that everyone who criticizes you is broken.
What should I say when someone is yelling at me?
Wait, then say something short that gives the fight nothing to grab. The wait is most of it. Answer at full heat and you’ll say the thing you can’t take back.
What I’d reach for:
- “That’s interesting.” Flat. Zero sarcasm, or it backfires.
- “Tell me more about that.” A lot of people can’t actually explain what they’re mad about when you ask them to spell it out. The temperature drops on its own.
- Nothing. Just wait. Most people can’t stand silence, so they keep talking, and sometimes they talk their way around to what they really meant.
- “I’ll think about that.” Then actually do, later, once you’re not wound up.
You’ll see people claim the brain needs exactly three seconds to come back online. I couldn’t find anything solid behind the number. Count to three anyway. Or ten. Or walk out of the room. Whatever gets you clear of the moment before you open your mouth.
Practice in traffic. Somebody cuts you off and your first thought is that they did it on purpose. They almost never did. They didn’t see you. Every time you let that one slide, you get a little better at letting other people’s shit roll off when it counts.
How do I find my own shadow?
Look at what makes you angrier than it should. Skip the mild annoyances and the honest disagreements. You’re looking for the kind of mad that follows you around for three days and keeps showing up in conversations about something else.
Then ask it some questions:
- The coworker who “hogs all the credit.” Do I want recognition and refuse to ask for it?
- The friend who’s “so dramatic.” Did I learn to be embarrassed by my own feelings?
- The guy who’s “so lazy.” Did I make being busy my entire identity?
- The person who “brags.” Did I make myself small so nobody could object to me?
A rough way to work it:
- Notice the big reaction. Treat it as information.
- Ask what you see in them that you wouldn’t allow in yourself.
- Admit it’s in you too, at least a little.
- Let it be there without acting on it. Having ambition doesn’t mean you have to step on people.
- Decide what to do with it. Put it to work, or set it down on purpose.
Do it the way you change your oil. Regularly, without making a big production of it, because things break down if you don’t. If it starts pointing at something heavy, go see a therapist. An article isn’t going to cover that.
Short version: quit fighting other people’s demons and go deal with yours.
Why does a tomato plant belong in an article about Jung?
Because a plant doesn’t care what you think. Most of the day happens on screens: threads, metrics, meetings, numbers standing in for other numbers. A plant needs water or it dies. You can’t argue it into growing and there’s no algorithm to game.
After a day of arguing with strangers, that’s a good reset. It’s also honest. The plant tells you pretty quick when you screwed up.
You don’t need a yard. A rental windowsill works:
- Herbs: basil, parsley, thyme, rosemary, cilantro. Basil wants real light. Thyme and rosemary forgive you for forgetting to water. Cilantro bolts fast when it’s warm, so sow more every few weeks.
- Scallions: use the green tops, stand the white root ends in a glass of water on the sill, and they grow back. You can do this a few rounds before they peter out.
- Cut-and-come-again lettuce: pick leaves and leave the plant. It handles partial shade better than most vegetables.
- Cherry tomatoes: the only tomato worth the trouble in a pot. Five gallons is the safe call. Dwarf varieties bred for containers can get by in less. Drainage holes either way.
Light is why most of this fails. Tomatoes want a lot of it, so you need a really sunny south window or a full-spectrum LED grow light. People growing tomatoes under lights usually run them around 14 to 16 hours a day on a timer, with a dark stretch at night. Lettuce and herbs get by on a lot less.
Buy potting mix. Dirt from outside packs down in a pot and won’t drain. Water when the top inch is dry, and don’t go by a schedule. People drown more houseplants than they neglect. And if a plant has looked dead for two weeks, quit watering it and hoping. Toss it in the compost and start over. Your first basil is going to die. So is your second, probably.
Frequently asked questions
What is shadow work in simple terms?
Shadow work is noticing the traits you’ve disowned and admitting they belong to you, so they stop running things from out of sight. It comes from Carl Jung’s idea of the shadow. It’s a self-reflection habit, and there’s little research showing it works as a treatment on its own.
How do I know if someone is projecting onto me?
Look for a reaction way bigger than the facts and an accusation that sounds more like a description of the person making it. Then check the claim on its merits anyway. If part of it is true, it’s feedback, and you should treat it that way.
What should I say to someone who is projecting?
Keep it short and calm. “That’s interesting,” “Tell me more about that,” or “I’ll think about it” all work because they give the other person nothing to push against. If you’re unsafe or it’s ongoing abuse, skip the technique and leave or get help.
Does shadow work replace therapy?
No. Jungian therapy has some outcome studies but no randomized trials, and shadow work as a standalone practice has almost no research behind it. If you’re dealing with trauma, depression or anxiety, see a licensed therapist. Plenty of them use Jungian ideas alongside methods with stronger evidence.
What are the easiest vegetables to grow in an apartment?
Scallions, cut-and-come-again lettuce, and herbs like parsley, thyme and basil are the easiest. Cherry tomatoes work if you have a very sunny window or a grow light and a pot around 5 gallons with drainage holes.
Next time somebody’s yelling at you, shut up for a few seconds. Then figure out if they’ve got a point.
Comments are open to members. Sign up free →